$120 vs $949 Audio Interface: Is an Expensive Interface Worth It?
I recorded the same guitar through a $120 Scarlett Solo and a $949 Clarett+ 4Pre. You can hear the difference. If you're new, it does not matter one bit.
Yes, you can hear the difference between a $120 Focusrite Scarlett Solo and a $949 Focusrite Clarett+ 4Pre. The Clarett is clearer, especially up top. BUT, if you're a beginner or an advanced beginner, it does not matter one bit. Spend the $800 on monitors, headphones, or room treatment instead.
Why did I even test this?
This was a happy accident! I was heading up to my mom's place in the country to write songs and capture some ideas, and I forgot the power adapter for my Clarett. So I stopped at Best Buy, and they had an open-box Scarlett Solo Gen 3 for 120 bucks.
I spent way too much time going over reviews and watching videos to make sure I bought the "right" audio interface and at the end of the day, it was a giant waste of time. When you're new to recording at home, it's easy to fall into the trap of wanting to buy a 'future proof' interface.
What if I want to record a real drumset? I'll need at least 8 inputs. What if my computer is slow, I'll need onboard DSP to process plugins!
I promise you, the cheapest possible interface is perfect. All you really need to decide on is how many inputs you really need. Me? I only really needed 2. A mic and line input (high-Z for guitars). It wasn't until I started recording with my band that I needed more inputs.
How did I set up the test?
As fair as I could make it:
- Same guitar (PRS SE), same pickups, same cable.
- Input gain matched on both so the loudest peaks hit about -12 dB.
- Air turned on for both interfaces.
- Softube Amp Room in Logic Pro for the amp sound.
- Zero processing on any of the audio. No EQ, no compression, nothing.
I recorded three versions on each: a gritty clean tone, a crunch tone, and the raw DI signal with no amp at all. I played each part as close to identical as a human can, which is not very, but close enough.
Scarlett Solo vs Clarett+ 4Pre: what's the spec difference?
| | Scarlett Solo (3rd Gen) | Clarett+ 4Pre |
|---|---|---|
| What I paid / list price | $120 open box (about $150 new) | $949 list |
| Mic preamps | 1 | 4 |
| Instrument inputs | 1 | 2 |
| Air mode | Yes | Yes, on all 4 pres |
| Total inputs / outputs | 2 in / 2 out | 18 in / 8 out (with ADAT) |
| Headphone outputs | 1 | 2 |
| MIDI in/out | No | Yes |
| Power | USB bus powered | Needs its own power supply |
| Max sample rate | 192 kHz | 192 kHz |
Focusrite says the Gen 3 Scarlett uses the same preamp design as their flagship gear. Maybe so. But the rest of the circuitry is different, and you can hear it. The Clarett sounds clearer and more open in the top end.
On the spec sheet, the big gap isn't sound quality. It's *how much stuff you can plug in at once*. That matters later. It doesn't matter on day one.
What are the pros of an expensive interface?
To be fair to the Clarett, it earns its keep in my studio:
- More inputs. I record a HeadRush DI and wet signal, a mic, and a direct guitar all at the same time. The Solo physically can't do that.
- Cleaner, clearer sound. It's real. You heard it in the video.
- Room to grow. ADAT means I can add eight more inputs later without replacing the interface.
- Two headphone outs and MIDI. Handy once you're tracking with someone else or running hardware.
And the cons?
- Price. Roughly $800 more for a difference most listeners will never notice in a finished song.
- Not portable. It needs wall power. That's literally why I ended up buying the Solo.
- It won't fix your mix. Not even a little.
For the record, I didn't pay $949. Focusrite used one of my previous videos to promote their FAST plugins, so I asked for a discount in exchange and got 50% off. I sold my old Scarlett 18i20 Gen 2 for about what I paid for the Clarett, so it was a wash for me.
So is it worth it if you're new?
No. Not even a few hundred dollars more.
If you're a beginner or advanced beginner, the interface is not your problem. I guarantee it. The hard stuff is learning your DAW, dealing with latency, learning compression and EQ, and figuring out mixing and mastering. That stuff will hold your songs back long before your preamps do.
I've seen comparison videos with spectrum analyzers on the noise floor proving one interface is quieter. That might be true. Nobody gives a shit when they're listening to a full song. Zero people listening to your music care which interface you used. What matters most is the song.
Take that $800 and buy decent studio monitors, good headphones, or some treatment for your room. You'll hear a much bigger difference.
FAQ
Can you hear the difference between a cheap and expensive audio interface?
Yes, on isolated guitar with headphones. The expensive interface sounds clearer. In a full mix, the difference shrinks to the point most people won't notice.
Is the Scarlett Solo good enough to record a song?
Yes, for one instrument or one vocal at a time. Its limit is inputs, not quality. If you need to record more than one mic and a guitar at once, you'll outgrow it.
When should I upgrade my audio interface?
When you run out of inputs, need to record several sources at once, or need more outputs for monitors and headphones. Not because you think it will make your recordings sound better.
Does Air mode make a difference?
It gives the high end a gentle lift. It was on for both interfaces in my test, so it wasn't the reason one sounded clearer than the other.
Bottom line
The $949 interface sounds better than the $120 one. If you're new, that does not matter. Learn to record, learn to mix, write better songs, and buy the cheap interface. Upgrade when you run out of inputs, not when you think gear is the problem.
Related posts
- Fender Highway Series vs Yamaha FGX800: Which Acoustic for Recording?
For a real acoustic tone on a recording, the $499 Yamaha FGX800 beats my $1,400 Fender Highway Series. The Fender wins on playability and as a second layer.
- Can You Use the Positive Grid Spark 40 as an Audio Interface for Logic Pro?
Yes. The Spark 40 connects by USB and appears in Logic Pro as an audio device, so you record the processed amp sound. Fine for demos, limiting for a release.
- Gold Tone AC-6 Six-String Banjo: Can a Guitar Player Use It on a Record?
Yes. The Gold Tone AC-6 is a six-string banjo in guitar tuning, so your chords work and it sounds like a banjo. The fastest way to add country texture.
Comments
Loading…
Sign in to leave a comment.